What's this game that we pretend to play Always a day too late to try and pick up that weight If you want me to try I will try until you're satisfied Promise if things go right we can go back if you'd like Stuck in between Caught in the meantime Always alone even the one time this feeling's let me in So it has to be just like you had imagined it'd be With a rope in your one hand and a rock in the other you'd swim for the shore I don't belong here and you don't belong here Let's swim for the shore Stuck in between Caught in the meantime Always alone even the one time this feeling's let me in When you were outside I was screaming your name through the radio And wouldn't I lie just to sing of your praise with hymns When you were gone I forgot how to make anything at all You left before it was time to go