Sheila was the one who thought she could remember Stood on the outside She would never call this home at all But there's no time Gets into the car Doesn't even answer Turn out the light I don't want to hear your voice We made a choice Let's drive all night Sheila was the one I couldn't even ask if she was all right This isn't you and I, it isn't even mine It's just less time We pass on Empty houses and broken lights Forgetting you there Always face turned aside I can't tell When you're crying from when you smile The radio plays These songs, they tell us lies Sheila was the one who thought we could forget her Stare from the outside Just then it wasn't right The rest of your life feels less in time I would never call and she would never answer That was all right This wasn't you and I Now don't even try There's no good bye Listen, just leave me here I never meant to make it home I know you thought I'd decide to stay Or maybe I was wrong and you just came to play along I'm sorry anyway