When you first came to me I wasn't sure what kind of game it would be But surprise of surprises, you were so kind to me Oh, my lady, so kind to me And the way you would tease me Soon began, began to please me And surprise of surprises, you were so kind to me Oh, my lady Straight through the middle of the way I was contentedly living Who's have thought you would ever stay Through the playwright's plot so timeless? Who'd have thought you would save the day Make each moment timeless? Who'd have thought you would ever stay? When you first came to me I wasn't sure what kind of game it would be But surprise of surprises, you were so kind to me Oh, my lady, oh, so kind to me, oh, my lady You were so kind to me You were so kind to me You were so kind to me