The first time I saw you Oh you looked so fine And I had a feeling One day you'd be mine Honey you came along and captured my heart Now my love is somewhere lost in your kiss When I'm all alone it's you that I miss Girl a love like yours is hard to resist Oh Oh Ooh Ooh Oh Penny lover my love's on fire Penny lover you're my one desire Tell me baby could this be true That I could need someone like I need you Nights warm and tender Lying next to you Girl I surrender Oh what more can I do I've spent all of my life in search of your love Now there's one more thing I'd like to say Don't you ever take your sweet love away Girl I'll do anything just please stay Oh Oh I don't understand it Oh what's come over me But I'm not gonna worry no not anymore 'Cause when a man's in love he's only got one story That's why my love is somewhere lost in your kiss When I'm lost and alone it's you that I miss With a love like yours it's hard to resist Ooh Ooh Oh Penny lover don't you walk on by Penny lover don't you make me cry don't you make me cry baby Penny lover don't you walk on by don't you walk on by Penny lover don't you make me cry Oh penny baby Penny lover don't you walk on by don't you walk on by I remember the first time I saw you baby Penny lover don't you make me cry You had the look in your eye you had the look in your eye Yeah Yeah